Searching For The Best Baby Mattress?

Searching For The Best Baby Mattress?

If your family is about to grow by two little feet, there’s a good chance you’re looking for the best baby mattress. You want your baby to be comfortable but most importantly you want them to be safe. We understand the seriousness of finding a quality sleeping surface for baby's crib, which is why we’ve done the research and come up with our list of possibilities for the ideal design for your baby's crib.

Take a moment to learn what to look and the safety requirements you should be aware of. With the help of Sleep Ask You’ll be able to navigate through the sea of products out there and find the perfect purchase, with plenty of time to spare before your new arrival shows up.

What to Look for in A Top Quality Design

When looking for bedding for infants, there are a few features you should focus on more than others. High quality products will focus on all the following features and leave you feeling confident in its safety.


A soft sleeping surface is never a good idea for new born's.  Your child can sink into it and if they happen to roll on their stomach, this can leave them with their head face down in the bedding that they can’t get out of. When it comes to safety make sure the sleeping surface is firm and level.


There’s no single type that’s considered to be supreme when it comes to crib bedding, but there are some differences between the different types that you should keep in mind.

Spring designs are a bit heavier so keep this in mind for late night accidents. You’ll have to lift the sleeping surface up to change the bedding and clean it. Foam designs are lighter, making bedding changes easier but if you plan on using the same sleeping surface as your baby grows and transitions to a toddler bed, a spring design might hold up better.


Make sure you check measurements before buying bedding for your infant. There should never be more than two inches between the sleeping surface  and the frame of the crib. This is just one of the reasons why its recommended to buy a new crib or one that’s no more than 10 years old. Crib manufacturers are now held to higher standards and are aware of the safety recommendations.

Are There Safety Requirements for Infant's Bedding?

This is an excellent question to ask when buying bedding for your infant. Yes,there are requirements in place by the Consumer Product Safety Commission that lay outgeneral guidelines for the all children's products producers. Here’s what to look for when researching safety requirements. 

    • A high quality model should have received the GREENGUARD Certification, which means the product will have low emissions of VOCs, or Volatile Organic Compounds, which lower the air quality in the room.
    • A high quality design will also have a CertiPUR certification, which means that there are no harmful materials added to the materials. This helps eliminate dangerous off-gassing and ensures that your baby is breathing in clean air throughout the night. This is not a required certification though, but superior designs  will have it.
    • Finally, make sure that your new product meets flammability requirements and that any of your personal requirements are met. For example, if you’re looking for a design made with natural materials or if you need a hypoallergenic cover.

Where to A Quality Product For My Child

It’s not difficult to find a selection of contenders.  Between department stores and specialized children's products stores, there are plenty you can go and see first-hand. This is a great idea if you’re having your first child since you have probably never shopped for the an infant's bedding  before. This will help you decide which features are important to you and help you understand the different types.

But when it comes to actually buying your new product, purchasing one off a site like Amazon is a great idea. You’ll save a little bit of money by cutting out the baby store prices and some purchases qualify for financing. This can come in handy when you’re making so many purchases for your new family member.

Does My Child's Bedding Have to New?

We understand that many families choose to buy certain children's products used. Certain items can certainly be purchased used, like clothing or easy to clean toys. But when it comes to sleeping surfaces, it’s always best to buy new and for several reasons.


Used bedding can have a variety of fluids locked in its layers from its previous user. Even if there are no visible stains,  there is almost guaranteed bacteria below the surface.

Bug Risks

Dust mites love to live in bedding. And you can’t see them. Since you don’t know the history of your used purchase, like how often it was cleaned or where it was stored, there’s a good chance you’re inviting a family of bed bugs into your home when you purchased it.

Poor Investment

Whether you buy new or used, you’re still putting money into your child's bedding.  When you buy used, there’s always the chance your purchase could give out within a month or two, wasting your investment. But when you buy new, you have the comfort of a warranty and a brand-new sleeping surface of course.

Another risk to keep in mind is that data has shown that infants who sleep on used bedding instead of of a new purchase, have a higher risk of SIDS, or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome. A study printed in the British Medical Journal concluded that, “…there is a valid statistical association between sudden infant death syndrome and use of an infant sleeping surface previously used by another child, particularly if from another home.”

For this reason alone, buying  new instead of used is a wise step to take towards your child's overall health and well being.

Here’s some overall safety tips for your child's nursery and crib.

Our Picks for A Superior Purchase 

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Looking for a superior product that comes in under budget? The Graco Premium is a great option to consider. It ships compressed and straight to your door so you can save the trip to the store. Just keep in mind that you’ll need to let the product expand for a full 48 hours before letting your child use it. This design features an inner-lining that’s water resistant for when accidents do happen. It meets federal flammability standards and is anti-microbial. With all of its added features, the Graco Premium is a great value and a definite possibility for your child.


  • Antimicrobial
  • Ships straight to your door
  • Water-resistant lining
  • 6-year warranty
  • Affordable


  • Needs 48 hours to expand
  • Some complaints of the design not fully expanding
Sealy Perfect Rest Infant-Toddler Crib Mattress

The Sealy Perfect is GREENGUARD GOLD certified so you can rest easy knowing your little one won’t be exposed to dangerous levels of air toxins while they sleep. It’s an innerspring design with 150 heavy gauge interlocking steel toils. They’re heat-tempered, making them stronger and more durable. This model should be able to keep up with your child as they grow and transfer to a toddler bed. The Sealy Perfect is also free of phthalates and contains only approved anti-flame materials. It’s a little pricier than other designs but it’s still affordable. With all of its features, it’s a great option for a quality sleeping surface for your child..


  • GREENGUARD GOLD certified
  • Innerspring
  • Phthalate-free
  • Tear resistant cover
  • Easy to wipe down


  • Could be too firm for toddlers
  • Coils can squeak over time
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant-Toddler Crib Mattress

The price of this contender is a little higher but you’re getting a high-quality design. The Sealy Soybean is of extra firm yet lightweight foam. It’s made with soybean oils provided by American farmers instead of using engineered materials. It’s GREENGUARD GOLD certified and has low chemical emissions that create a safe and healthy sleeping environment for your child. If you’re looking for ta great product and have a larger budget, consider the award-winning Sealy Soybean.


  • Award winning design
  • GREENGUARD GOLD certified
  • Made with natural oils
  • Low chemical emissions
  • High quality


  • More expensive than other models
  • Might be to firm for a toddler
Safety 1stTransitions Baby and Toddler Mattress

If you want to ensure that your new product will remain comfortable and safe throughout their toddler years, the Safety 1st Transitions design could be an ideal option for you. It has two different firmness levels. One side of the surface is firmer and ideal for newborns while the other is softer and perfect for toddlers. The toddler side also has an additional cushioning layer. The product has been GREENGUARD GOLD certified and meets all federal flammability standards.


  • GREENGUARD GOLD certified
  • Dual sided
  • Designed to adjust to your child’s growing needs
  • Lightweight
  • Fits both cribs and toddler beds


  • Be sure to measure before ordering-too big for some cribs
  • Not as durable as designs with coils

Our Top Choice For Ideal Product For Infants 

Looking for a high quality product is a serious job. So if we had to point you towards just one of the designs we’ve recommended, it would be the Safety 1st Transitions. It’s designed for both infants and toddlers. Because it’s designed to last, it’s a great value. Safety 1st has thought of everything. It’s firm enough for a newborn to meet safety regulations but soft enough on the opposite side to be comfortable for toddlers. Even though it’s foam, it’s still an incredibly durable design that is, in our opinion, one of the most superior designs on the market.